A Brand Turnaround Needs More Than a New Campaign

Companies love launching campaigns. New tagline. New commercial. New influencer partnership. New creative agency. Then six months later someone asks why sales have not changed. Two very different brands, Athleta and Wendy's, are currently confronting the same marketing problem: a company cannot promote its way out of an unclear identity. <h2>Athleta Is Sharpening Its Brand World</h2> Athleta is trying to sharpen what the brand represents through its new "My World. My Rules." platform. The campaign puts greater emphasis on emotional storytelling, stronger visuals and a more clearly defined point of view around women. Athleta describes the effort as part of building a more distinctive, "female-first" brand world rather than simply pushing products. The shift comes while Athleta itself is rebuilding. Comparable sales fell 11% in the quarter ending May 2, while sister brand Gap posted growth. Gap Inc. has described 2026 as a rebuilding period for Athleta. <h2>Wendy's Is Rebuilding From the Top</h2> Meanwhile, Wendy's has made an equally interesting move. The company hired former McDonald's U.S. marketing executive Tariq Hassan into the newly created position of chief marketing and customer growth officer. Hassan previously worked on culturally relevant McDonald's campaigns including the adult Happy Meal and Grimace's birthday. But Wendy's problem is bigger than finding someone capable of creating viral moments. Wendy's leadership has acknowledged that the brand became too dependent on individual promotions and collaborations instead of maintaining a consistent story about what Wendy's actually represents. The company is trying to reverse six consecutive quarters of same-store sales declines. That distinction is extremely important. <h2>Viral Is Not the Same as Valuable</h2> Wendy's has been one of the most recognizable corporate personalities on social media. People know the jokes. People screenshot the posts. People share the roasts. But awareness and engagement do not automatically equal revenue. A million views can be impressive while producing almost no meaningful business result. Athleta has another version of the same challenge. The company has talked about empowerment before. Its previous "Find Your Movement" platform also centered on similar ideas, but the messaging did not create the growth the company wanted. Its latest strategy is attempting to make that identity sharper, more emotional and harder to confuse with competitors. Both brands are arriving at the same realization: Marketing becomes stronger when the customer understands the brand before they see the promotion. <h2>Businesses Need a Narrative Before They Need Content</h2> This applies far beyond billion-dollar companies. Ask a small business owner what makes the company different and you often hear: Great service. Quality work. Competitive pricing. Family owned. Twenty years of experience. The problem is that thousands of competitors say exactly the same thing. Marketing becomes easier when a company develops a clear point of view. What do you believe? Who specifically are you for? What problem are you unusually good at solving? What should someone immediately associate with your name? Once those answers are clear, advertising becomes amplification. Without them, advertising becomes noise. <h2>Consistency Beats Random Creativity</h2> Athleta is trying to create a platform it can build from. Wendy's is trying to move away from a calendar filled with disconnected promotions. That is the lesson businesses should pay attention to. A strong brand does not need to reinvent itself every Tuesday. The same core idea should appear in your website, sales calls, social content, paid ads, reviews, customer experience and follow-up. Creative executions can change. The narrative should remain recognizable. Because customers rarely remember every advertisement. They remember what they believe a company stands for. And ultimately, that perception is the brand.

Back to all articles Get your free market report